Skip to Main Content

Islington Branch Book Club - Past Titles: "Death Comes to Pemberley" by P. D. James

Take a look through previous titles we've discussed at our Islington Branch Book Club

"Death Comes to Pemberley" by P. D. James

  1. Character Exploration:

    • How does P.D. James stay true to the characterization of the original "Pride and Prejudice" characters while also developing them further in "Death Comes to Pemberley"?
    • Analyze the character of Fitzwilliam Darcy in this novel. How does his role as a husband, father, and estate owner influence his actions and decisions in the face of the murder investigation?
  2. Theme of Justice:

    • Discuss the theme of justice as it unfolds in the novel. How do the characters' perceptions of justice align with or diverge from societal expectations during the Regency era?
    • Consider the role of the justice system and legal procedures depicted in the novel. How do they reflect the societal attitudes and limitations of the time?
  3. Exploration of Relationships:

    • Explore the dynamics of the relationships between characters such as Elizabeth and Darcy, Georgiana and Wickham, and the Bennet family members. How do these relationships evolve or change in light of the murder investigation?
    • Discuss the portrayal of marriage and family life in "Death Comes to Pemberley." How does the murder investigation impact the relationships within the Darcy and Bennet families?
  4. Mystery and Suspense:

    • Evaluate the effectiveness of the murder mystery plot in engaging readers. How does P.D. James create and sustain suspense throughout the novel?
    • Discuss the clues, red herrings, and plot twists employed by the author. Were you surprised by the resolution of the mystery, or did you anticipate the outcome?
  5. Literary Homage:

    • Consider the ways in which P.D. James pays homage to Jane Austen's writing style and themes in "Death Comes to Pemberley." How does she capture the tone and spirit of Austen's work while adding her own twist with the murder mystery plot?
    • Discuss the significance of setting the novel in the world of "Pride and Prejudice." How does the familiar backdrop of Pemberley and its surrounding society contribute to the story?
  6. Social Commentary:

    • Explore the social commentary embedded in the novel, particularly regarding class, gender roles, and the power dynamics of Regency-era England.
    • Discuss how the murder investigation exposes underlying tensions and societal expectations related to class differences and reputations.
  7. Character Motivations:

    • Analyze the motivations of the various characters involved in the murder case. How do their personal histories, desires, and secrets influence their actions and decisions?
    • Consider the role of pride, prejudice, and social status in shaping characters' motivations and behaviors.
  8. Resolution and Closure:

    • Reflect on the resolution of the murder mystery and its implications for the characters and their relationships. Were you satisfied with how the various plot threads were resolved?
    • Discuss any lingering questions or unresolved issues that you feel could have been addressed differently in the novel.
  9. Comparative Analysis:

    • Compare and contrast P.D. James's portrayal of the characters from "Pride and Prejudice" with Jane Austen's original characterization. How do their interpretations align with or diverge from Austen's depictions?
  10. Reader Reflection:

    • How did reading "Death Comes to Pemberley" enhance or alter your appreciation of "Pride and Prejudice"? Did it add new dimensions to the characters and their world, or did it detract from your enjoyment of Austen's classic novel?

P.D. James, born Phyllis Dorothy James, was a renowned British author of crime fiction, best known for her detective novels featuring the fictional character Adam Dalgliesh. Here's a brief biography of P.D. James:

Early Life and Career: Phyllis Dorothy James was born on August 3, 1920, in Oxford, England. She grew up in a middle-class family, and her early years were marked by challenges, including her parents' separation and her mother's mental illness. Despite these difficulties, James developed a love for literature and writing from a young age.

At the age of sixteen, James had to leave school due to her family's financial struggles and began working as a civil servant in various government departments. She later joined the National Health Service (NHS), where she worked for many years, eventually rising to the position of administrative assistant in the Hospital Administration Division.

Literary Career: James began her writing career in the late 1950s while still working for the NHS. Her first novel, "Cover Her Face," featuring the character Adam Dalgliesh, was published in 1962. This marked the beginning of her prolific career as a crime fiction writer.

Over the decades, James wrote a total of fourteen Adam Dalgliesh novels, which garnered critical acclaim and a dedicated readership. Her novels are known for their intricate plots, atmospheric settings, and psychologically complex characters.

In addition to the Adam Dalgliesh series, James wrote several standalone novels, including "Innocent Blood," "The Children of Men," and "The Murder Room." She also published works of non-fiction, including her memoir "Time to Be in Earnest" and "Talking About Detective Fiction," a reflection on the genre.

Legacy and Recognition: P.D. James's contributions to the crime fiction genre were widely celebrated during her lifetime. She received numerous awards for her work, including the Crime Writers' Association Diamond Dagger for Lifetime Achievement and the Mystery Writers of America Grand Master Award.

James's novels have been adapted for television and film, further cementing her legacy in popular culture. Her writing continues to be admired for its literary quality, intellectual depth, and exploration of human nature.

P.D. James passed away on November 27, 2014, at the age of 94. Despite her death, her legacy as one of the most influential crime fiction writers of the 20th century endures, and her novels continue to be read and appreciated by audiences around the world.


Westwood Public Library

Main Library

660 High Street
Westwood, MA 02090
Email Main Library

Islington Branch

273 Washington Street
Westwood, MA 02090
Email Branch Library